towardia Where things come from.
Englishen

Earl Grey or English Breakfast

Both are black tea from Camellia sinensis, and both sit side by side in tea bags on the shelf. The difference is where the taste comes from: Earl Grey is flavoured with bergamot oil, while English Breakfast is a blend of Assam and Ceylon with no additions.

Earl Grey tea English Breakfast tea
CompositionBlend of China black teas plus bergamot oil (UKTIA)Assam and Ceylon, often African tea (UKTIA)
FlavouringBergamot, Citrus bergamia RissoNone
TasteBlack tea with a citrus, perfumed aromaStrong: malty Assam and brisk Ceylon
Steeping time3–4 min (UKTIA)Components 3–4 min; Ceylon Uva 3 min
Water and dose90–98 °C, one bag or a rounded teaspoon per cup90–98 °C, one bag or a rounded teaspoon per cup
MilkWith or withoutAssam and Ceylon with or without; Kenyan with milk
Documented historyEarl Grey's mixture in an 1884 advert; Earl Grey tea from 1929 (OED)No reliable primary source
EU labelRegulation 1334/2008, Art. 16: natural bergamot flavouring means at least 95 % bergamotNo specific naming rules; PA limit 150 µg/kg, as for any tea

Which to choose

If you want a citrus aroma, choose Earl Grey and check the flavouring line. If you want a strong tea for milk, choose English Breakfast with Kenyan tea in the blend. In both, the black base sets the caffeine: USDA lists 20 mg per 100 g of brew.

Frequently asked questions

Which one has more caffeine?

There are no separate figures for either blend; both have a black base, and USDA gives brewed black tea 20 mg per 100 g.

Which one is better with milk?

Both are drunk with or without milk, but UKTIA lists the Kenyan tea in English Breakfast specifically as a tea for milk.

Do Earl Grey and English Breakfast brew the same way?

Yes: both are black tea, brewed with water at 90–98 °C for 3–4 minutes.

Sources

Themes