Protected and generic food names
Also known as: generic food names, can it be called parmesan, what can be called feta, protected vs generic names
Why Parmesan and feta in the EU must be the real thing, while gouda, camembert or balsamic vinegar can be made by anyone: where the line between protected and generic names runs.
Protected and generic names are the line that decides whether a Polish cheese may be called Parmesan or a German one gouda. A protected name may be used in the EU only on a product that meets the registered specification. A generic name may be used by anyone, because it has long meant a type of food rather than a place.
The best-known disputes were settled by the EU Court of Justice. In 2005 it confirmed that feta is a protected Greek name, not a generic word for brined white cheese. In 2008 it held that Parmesan evokes Parmigiano Reggiano, so grated cheese from another country may not be sold under that word in the EU. In 2019, by contrast, it ruled that the separate words aceto and balsamico are not protected: only the full name Aceto Balsamico di Modena is.
For many cheeses it is the longer name, not the single word, that is protected. Anyone may make gouda, but Gouda Holland only in the Netherlands. Camembert is generic, while Camembert de Normandie is a designation of origin. The same goes for brie and Brie de Meaux, and for cheddar and West Country Farmhouse Cheddar. Mozzarella is generic with a separate traditional speciality guaranteed, while Mozzarella di Bufala Campana is a protected designation.
How to check: look for the full name and the EU seal. If a pack says Parmesan without Parmigiano Reggiano, or feta that is not from Greece, that breaks the rules in the EU; outside the EU the rules may differ.
Why it matters to you: the same word on the shelf does not mean the same product. Gouda and Gouda Holland, camembert and Camembert de Normandie may sit side by side and differ greatly in price and origin; the seal, not the word, explains the difference.
A name cannot be both generic and protected: generic names cannot be registered as protected names, and a registered name cannot later become generic. In the Feta case the Court also looked at how people actually understand the word. Most Greek consumers see it as a geographical name, which counted against calling it generic. Most Danish consumers, by contrast, saw it as a generic word, so perception varies by country.
How it connects to Food labels & standards
Protected and generic food names → similar → 🏷️ Protected designation of origin (PDO) → kind of → 🏷️ How to read a food label
Links
- Part of
- Origin and protected names
- Similar and different
- 🏷️ Protected designation of origin (PDO), 🍷 Protected geographical indication
- In other topics
- 🧀 Parmesan, 🧀 Feta, 🧀 Gouda, 🧀 Gouda Holland
- What defines it?
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1143 on geographical indications
Frequently asked questions
Can cheese from outside Italy be called Parmesan in the EU?
No. In 2008 the EU Court ruled that Parmesan evokes Parmigiano Reggiano, so other cheese may not use the name.
Is cheddar a protected name?
No, cheddar is generic and made worldwide; only West Country Farmhouse Cheddar, made on farms in four English counties to a traditional method, is protected.
Is Parmesan protected in the US or UK?
In the US Parmesan is treated as a generic name. In the UK Parmigiano Reggiano stayed protected after Brexit under the UK's own geographical indication scheme.
Is the word balsamic protected?
No. In 2019 the EU Court ruled that only the full name Aceto Balsamico di Modena is protected, not its separate words.
Is it true that any white brined cheese can be called feta?
No. Since 2005 feta has been a protected Greek name in the EU; similar cheese from elsewhere may not use it.
What to read next
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1143 on geographical indications — The EU law on protected names: PDO, PGI and TSG for food, wine and spirits in one system; applies from 13 May 2024 and replaced Regulation 1151/2012.
- 🏷️ Protected designation of origin (PDO) — The EU mark for a product made entirely in one defined area, from raw material to finished food, under registered rules.
- 🍷 Protected geographical indication — A protected name for wine from an area with looser rules.
Similar
Sources
- Court of Justice of the EU, Case C-132/05 Commission v Germany (Parmesan), 26.02.2008 — EUR-Lex
- Court of Justice of the EU, Joined Cases C-465/02 and C-466/02 (Feta), 25.10.2005 — EUR-Lex
- Court of Justice of the EU, Case C-432/18 (Balsamico), 04.12.2019 — EUR-Lex
- eAmbrosia — EU register
- University of Reading food law news, Feta
- LSE Research Online, generic use and Feta
- Marques, generic names and registration
