Black Forest ham or Speck Alto Adige: the difference
Schwarzwälder Schinken from Germany and Speck Alto Adige from Italian South Tyrol are two PGI boneless hams, both cold-smoked. The difference lies in smoke, temperature, timing and the brine rest.
| 🍖 Schwarzwälder Schinken | Speck Alto Adige | |
|---|---|---|
| Country and protection | Germany, Black Forest; PGI, Reg. (EC) 123/97 | Italy, province of Bolzano; PGI, Reg. (EC) 1107/96 |
| Cut | Boneless hind leg, with or without the top round; white fat rim | Boned, trimmed hind leg; «baffa» of 5.2 kg or more |
| Salting | Dry, with a spice blend (salt, pepper, coriander, garlic, juniper); several weeks in its own brine; no injection | Lightly salted and spiced, within 4 days of a recorded start date |
| Smoking | Cold smoke of fir logs and sawdust, +20 to +30 °C, at least a week | Cold smoke up to 20 °C |
| Time | About 12 weeks from salting (producers' association), weight loss about 25%; no legal minimum | About 22 weeks (consortium); ageing at 10-16 °C |
| Taste | Smoke, clear ham flavour, nutty spiced fat | Smoky, spiced, intense but not salty; salt up to 5% |
| Label | Name and PGI logo (g.g.A.), dark surface, white fat rim; degreased ham may not use the name | PGI logo, name «Speck Alto Adige» or «Südtiroler Speck» with «IGP», hot brand with the producer's code |
Which to choose
Both are boneless leg with cold smoke, so the difference is subtler than it looks. Black Forest ham is smoked over fir for at least a week, ripens about 12 weeks and tastes clearly of smoke. Speck Alto Adige is smoked more lightly, up to 20 °C, and ages about 22 weeks. For a piece with bread either works; choose by the name, the PGI and the fat rim.
Frequently asked questions
Is Black Forest ham the same as speck?
No. Black Forest ham is always the leg, rests in its own brine and is smoked over fir. Speck Alto Adige is an Italian PGI from the leg, cold-smoked at up to 20 °C.
Which ages longer?
By the producers' own figures, Black Forest ham about 12 weeks and Speck Alto Adige about 22 weeks.
Is it true that pigs for Black Forest ham are raised in the Black Forest?
No. The specification requires all processing in the Black Forest but does not restrict where the pigs are raised.
Sources
- Amendment application and single document Schwarzwälder Schinken, OJ C 274, 11.9.2012
- Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 561/2013
- Schwarzwälder Schinken, 1997 registration summary (eAmbrosia)
- Schutzverband der Schwarzwälder Schinkenhersteller, flyer 2023
- eAmbrosia, Speck Alto Adige PGI
- Consorzio Tutela Speck Alto Adige
